The israel lobby is responsible for its fair share of catastrophesbut the iraq war is not among them. The israel lobby revisited it has been 21 months since john mearsheimer and steve walt published their article the israel lobby and u. Dont blame the iraq debacle on the israel lobby part 12. Foreign policy is a book by john mearsheimer, professor of political science at the university of chicago, and stephen walt, professor of international relations at the kennedy school of government at harvard university, published in late august 2007.
Stephen zunes is a professor of politics and chair of the middle eastern studies program at the university of san francisco, where he has taught since 1995. I went to the index in the back of the book picked a topic and then went and read the pages noted. The israel lobby is responsible for its fair share of catastrophesbut the iraq war is. Reading the israel lobby and us foreign policy is a rather dispiriting experience when one grasps how highly lauded it is by so many people.
As me scholar stephen zunes has rightly pointed out, there are far more powerful interests that have a stake in what happens in the persian gulf region than does aipac or the lobby generally, such as the oil companies, the arms industry and other special interests whose lobbying influence. It has been 21 months since john mearsheimer and steve walt published their article the israel lobby and u. Stephen zunes, a foreign policy in focus columnist and senior analyst, is a professor of politics and chair of middle eastern studies at the university of san francisco. May 12, 2010 stephen zunes, defending israel while challenging its policies, in alan dershowitz ed. Writing in foreign policy in focus, zunes recently offered an analysis of john mearsheimer and stephen walts israel lobby essay that was similar in some ways to the negative views of leftist luminaries chomsky and norman finkelstein but reflected a more hostile tone not just toward mearsheimer and walt but toward anyone who would dare claim that the israel lobby has had an impact on american foreign policy. Nov 27, 2014 the first is to see the israel lobby as a wellcrafted attempt to divert blame for the costly debacle that the invasion of iraq has become from the rest of the establishment, especially the oil lobby, to the ageold scapegoat, the jews zunes 2006b. Foreign policy kindle edition by mearsheimer, john j. Here, it is generally referred to as the israel lobby or the proisrael lobby, so plitnick is creating a straw man. Its tendency to emphasize israel s offenses while largely overlooking those of its adversaries has troubled even many doves. The israel lobby by stephen zunes november 1, 2007. The israel lobby revisited by zunes, stephen foreign. In 1931 the gershwin brothers wrote of thee i sing, the first musical to win a pulitzer. Sep 21, 2011 furthermore zunes 2009 argues that aid given to israel is not due to the lobby but is a reflection of israels strategic importance to the us. Jul 01, 2006 an editorial judging from the ferocity of reactions to the israel lobby and u.
The largest proisrael lobbying group is christians united. The term, the jewish lobby is how it is referred to, and not too favorably, in israels hebrew press, so perhaps, plitnick should address that issue there. Years after noam chomsky, stephen zunes, walter russell mead and many others published their critiques of the stephen walt and john mearsheimer israel lobby thesis, many of the sharpest critics of israel continue to attribute us foreign policy in the middle east to the influence of the lobby. In the pages that follow, we describe how the israel lobby has accomplished this feat. The israel lobby at times called the zionist lobby is the diverse coalition of those who, as individuals andor as groups, seek to influence the foreign policy of the united states in support of israel or the policies of the government of israel. Mearsheimer of the university of chicago and stephen m. Furthermore zunes 2009 argues that aid given to israel is not due to the lobby but is a reflection of israels strategic importance to the us. The nasty campaign waged against john mearsheimer and stephen walt has itself provided an excellent example of.
Facebook gives people the power to share and makes the world more open and connected. Foreign policy, by john mearsheimer of the university of chicago and stephen walt of harvard university, has come under attack from various quarters. As a result, it is all too easy to buy into the arguments. President trumps announcement on wednesday that the united states formally recognizes jerusalem as the capital of israel and that the u. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the israel lobby and u. Dec 23, 2007 it has been 21 months since john mearsheimer and steve walt published their article the israel lobby and u. Similarly, in his refutation of israel lobby thesis, zunes 2006a, p. These controversial policies therefore are in line with the narrow idea of national interest carried out by us governments, not. Recently published by stephen zunes sudans democratic revolution. Kennedy school of government, was one of the most controversial articles in recent memory. The bankruptcy of the mainstream left as illustrated by stephen zunes, or, on the issue of the israel lobby the left is no more courageous than anyone else. Its tendency to emphasize israels offenses while largely overlooking those of its adversaries has troubled even many doves. Stephen zunes argues that the blame for the iraq war should not be put on the israel lobby, but the bush administration and us imperialism.
Stephen zun es born 1956 is an american international relations scholar specializing in the middle eastern politics, u. The israel lobby revisited organic consumers association. Buy the israel lobby and us foreign policy 01 by mearsheimer, john j, walt, stephen m isbn. May 14, 20 stephen zunes argues that the blame for the iraq war should not be put on the israel lobby but the bush administration and us imperialism. Foreign policy 9780374177720 by mearsheimer, john j walt, stephen m.
An editorial judging from the ferocity of reactions to the israel lobby and u. As a result, it is all too easy to buy into the arguments put forward by john mearsheimer and steve walt in their newlyreleased book the israel lobby and u. An article in the jewish journal forward quotes m as saying that the article was commissioned by a us journal, but rejected, and that the proisrael lobby is so powerful that he and coauthor stephen walt would never have been able to place their report in a americanbased scientific publication. Itamar rabinovich discusses the phenomenon of john mearsheimer and stephen walts recent book the israel lobby and notes that it should give israel and its friends pause. The overbearing power and mccarthyite tactics wielded by the american jewish establishment against critics of israeli government policies has made critical discourse about u. He is the author, along with jacob mundy, of western sahara. Foreign policy farrar, straus, and giroux, 2007 that the israel lobby is primarily responsible for the tragic course taken in u. Sep 29, 2007 the israel lobby and us foreign policy by john j mearsheimer and stephen m walt 496pp, allen lane. A native of north carolina, professor zunes received his phd. Dont blame the iraq debacle on the israel lobby fpif.
Dont blame the iraq debacle on the israel lobby part 22. Ten years ago, i wrote a series of articles for the foreign policy in focus website in which i put forth a series of arguments against the bush administrations push for a u. Here as an example of the influence of the israel lobby we might look to stephen greens book, taking sides, americas secret relations with. And even when the themes were familiar, they were backed up. The lobby consists of secular, christian, and jewishamerican individuals and groups. Dec 20, 2007 it has been 21 months since john mearsheimer and steve walt published their article the israel lobby and u.
Noam chomsky and steven zunesas well as by fervent defenders. Foreign policy r wendell harrison distinguished service professor of political science codirector of the program on international security policy john j mearsheimer, john j. He is known internationally as a leading critic of united states policy in the middle east, particularly under the george w. Washington report on middle east affairs, mayjune 2005. A progressive response to mearsheimer and walt by stephen zunes an iranian boy on a relative s shoulders looks at a poster during an antiwar demonstration in tehran, iran, march, 2003. An article in the jewish journal forward quotes m as saying that the article was commissioned by a us journal, but rejected, and that the pro israel lobby is so powerful that he and coauthor stephen walt would never have been able to place their report in a americanbased scientific publication. Bush administration, and an analyst of nonviolent civil insurrections against autocratic regimes. In my humble opinion it was loaded with too many facts your head starts swimming,so i took a different approach to the book. Walt is the robert and renee belfer professor of international affairs at the harvard kennedy school and the coauthor with john j. The publication in march 2006 of the israel lobby and u. How they did it 26 february 2020 sanders is not another mcgovern. Stephen zunes born 1956 is an american international relations scholar specializing in the middle eastern politics, u. Given the enormous tragedy of the us invasion of iraq, the wars tenth anniversary has inevitably raised the question of why.
A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Stephen zunes, defending israel while challenging its policies, in alan dershowitz ed. The first is to see the israel lobby as a wellcrafted attempt to divert blame for the costly debacle that the invasion of iraq has become from the rest of the establishment, especially the oil lobby, to the ageold scapegoat, the jews zunes 2006a. Walt is the belfer professor of international affairs at the john f. Us hegemony, not the lobby, behind complicity with israel. Stephen zunes, an editorial fellow at the tikkun institute, is a professor of politics at the university of san francisco. Stephen zunes is a professor of politics and international studies at the university of san francisco, where he serves as coordinator of the program in middle eastern studies. Bush is perfectly capable of doing stupid things himself without the israel lobby forcing his hand. Stephen zunes has been at usf since 1995, teaching courses on the politics of middle east and other regions, nonviolence, conflict resolution, u. Zunes argues that antiamericanism in the middle east is a response.
These controversial policies therefore are in line with the narrow idea of national interest carried out by us governments, not because the israel lobby diverted foreign policy. Discover book depositorys huge selection of stephen zunes books online. Stephen zunes, a foreign policy in focus columnist and senior analyst, is a. Recognized as one the countrys leading scholars of u. Kennedy school of government at harvard university, and was academic dean of the kennedy school from 2002 to 2006. The nasty campaign waged against john mearsheimer and stephen walt has itself provided an excellent example of the bullying tactics used by the lobby and its supporters. War, nationalism, and conflict irresolution syracuse university press, 2010. Mar 29, 20 dont blame the iraq debacle on the israel lobby the israel lobby is responsible for its fair share of catastrophesbut the iraq war is not among them. Zunes contribution to this book by the notorious alan dershowitz speaks volumes of the manner by which zunes is willing to lend his antiimperial writings to support zionism. Foreign policy is a book by john mearsheimer, professor of political science at the university of chicago, and stephen walt. Stephen zunes university of san francisco, ca usfca. How can they be so impotent in the face of the lobby. The world according to us empire by julian assange was to me a very difficult book to read. As me scholar stephen zunes has rightly pointed out, there are far more.
976 1200 354 874 526 1016 82 1523 1024 1376 693 990 781 28 504 494 1625 1100 851 1201 294 872 634 1493 1414 1303 950 1349 427 1008 61 788 126 1195 655